Thursday, September 23, 2010

This is not Governance

The Supreme Court today saved us from having to hear the Ayodhya verdict tomorrow. India's civil society heaved a collective sigh of relief and prepared to get on with life until the next "date" for the verdict. I admire the way the SC handled the situation -- postpone the verdict a day before it is due, next hearing about when the verdict can be delivered two days before the judge delivering the verdict retires, thus paving the way for a lengthy re-trial.

On the other hand, I am completely appalled by the reaction of the Karnataka government.When faced with the possibility of a law and order situation following the verdict, the CM, instead of taking preventive measures by taking lumpen elements into custody and sending out a stern warning to hooligans, decided to ... impose curfew for students of all ages! All public and private schools and colleges were declared shut for two days.

This knee-jerk surrender to the lawless will just strengthen the hands of the lumpen elements of society who are always on the lookout for an excuse to cause trouble.

The *correct* response from a good government would have been to tell parents to send their children to school and take responsibility of their safety, while dealing strongly with potential troublemakers, thus sending a message that society cannot be held to ransom by those who flout the law.

Increasingly, it seems to me that law and order is becoming meaningless in India -- might is what prevails. Why then do we need governments at all, if at the time for governance, they helplessly throw up their hands and lock up the innocent?

1 comment:

  1. well said madam. and true, the govts in general in our country lack political courage. I think it died with sardar patel.

    ReplyDelete